357 vs 10mm bear.

A huge boost to the popularity of the 10mm is the trend of foregoing the traditionally accepted .44 Magnum (or larger) revolver in favor of the lighter, higher-capacity 10mm for bear defense. The 10mm has generated a pretty good track record of defense against grizzlies and brown bears, and a 10mm is much easier to carry and shoot accurately ...357 mag vs black bear. ... Even Grizzly Bear have been stopped by 10mm Auto, which is roughly equal to .357 Magnum, albeit with a larger diameter bullet. Elmer Keith, an accomplished rancher, outdoorsman, and big game hunter who played a large role in the development of both the .357 Magnum, .41 Magnum, and .44 Magnum cartridges, once said that ...Ep. 330 | 9mm vs 10mm — Bear Defense Breakdown. Back from shooting 9mm and 10mm pistols at charging paper targets, ballistic gel blocks, and bear skulls, Mark Boardman and Ryan Muckenhirn have a lot to dig... www.youtube.com. Hmmmmm, I was seriously considered getting a " 10mm Glock "... However, after doing lots of research, in particular ...Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...Firearm Discussion and Resources from AR-15, AK-47, Handguns and more! Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear.

Brown bear shot by policemen s after attack on veterinarian,police uses that time (2010) 9mm Makarov, I'm pretty sure about 95% it was basic FMJ (Full metal ...1,583. Overdrive said: I'm electing to use 200 gr Underwood hard cast in my 10mm. I don't need to worry about Brown bears where I'm at. Mainly carrying for protection against black bear, mountain lion and wolves. Plus the 200 gr meets state regs for pistol ft/lbs if I have a bear license in my pocket I can harvest one while guiding (but ...

10mm vs. .357 Magnum for bear protection? in Episode 3 we have Underwood Xtreme Penetrators and more redneck science. What do you use for bear protection? S...Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...

Sep 5, 2018 · Minimum caliber is 4x against bear. Follow the 4-3-1 rule. 4x caliber and up. 300 grain and up. At least 1000 FPS. Your 5.56 meets only one criterion. Many people carry a 45-70. I carry a Ruger Alaskan 454 Casull or a Ruger Toklat 454 Casull. But I’m in black bear country. 10mm Auto or 44 Magnum for Bear defense, that is the question! Revolver or high capacity automatic? I note actual Bear charges that people have used pistols...A .357, 10mm, .41, or .44 are your ideal pistols in bear country. I rock a G20 with an aftermarket 6.6″ LoneWolf barrel and a magazine of 200gr hard cast rounds. That would easily kill a bear up here. ... Lets make this very clear. A 10mm or a .357 WILL kill any bear. If you arent a good enough shot, or dont know where to shoot a bear, then ...In the supplied chart, 357 Magnum recoil was calculated with a 42-ounce Colt Python, and the 9mm Luger with a 40-ounce Colt 1911. Given handguns of similar weight, the 357 Magnum recoils with ...However, I'm not in bear country and for the most part I'd rather have a 357 loaded with 2 rounds of snake shot as the 1st 2 rounds, because snakes suck and I do live in snake country View Quote Yeah, I'd take a 10mm over 9mm any day if I'm facing down a bear.

If you want a pistol that can take down a mountain lion but is also easier to carry than a .357 hand cannon for self-defense, the 10mm is the perfect option. ... Trophy Bonded Bear Claw 10mm offers deep penetration and reliable expansion. Federal Premium.

9mm and 10mm had almost identical results when passing through gel- 69 inches of gel for both 9mm and 10mm had very similar results when passing through the synthetic bear head- both had straight line penetration, and both had some shots that deflected in some fashion Both guys agree 9mm punched above expectations

Firearm Discussion and Resources from AR-15, AK-47, Handguns and more! Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear.A more accurate comparison would be to par the 10mm Auto to a full-house .357 Magnum in a 5″-6″ barrel. As you can see, the .357 Magnum produces ballistics that more closely compare to the 10mm Auto. Having said that, 10mm fans should not feel down and blue. The .357 Mag is arguably one of the best man-stoppers in the handgun world.Recently a guy in my State had a glock 10mm in his pocket and shot himself while in a tree stand, (going up or down I don't know.) The 10mm is a great round for your intended purpose. I also appreciate the 357 sig. With bear defense I may just go with a solid flat point round. Good luck with your search.38 posts · Joined 2015. #1 · Aug 8, 2015. I am trying to decide whether to carry a Super Blackhawk .44 mag. with 3.75 inch barrel or a Magnum Research .454 Casull with 5 inch barrel as grizzly repellant flyfishing the Rockies. At the moment I am thinking either would be loaded with 300 grain or heavier hard cast lead bullets,etc.There are many great options for bear defense handguns, and 10mm pistols are rapidly becoming the most popular. Tyler Freel. We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs. Learn More ›.I'd have a lot more faith in the reliability of a 1911A1 in 10mm than one in .357 magnum. Neither caliber will reliably stop a bear of any description with one shot. …

The practical end uses of the .357 are many and varied, such as hunting, self-defense (plenty of stopping power), home defense and target shooting. It’s also very forgiving to make handloads for. Guns as small as the S&W J-Frame are readily available and carry easily. The .44 Magnum, on the other hand, struggles greatly in small guns.Originally Posted by OSOKSo, Kevin, why are you getting in so many fights with black bears? Are you out there calling them names or something? Lotsa youth, not much brains. I have mellowed in my later years and I now no longer push any issue with a bear unless he's on my property. Have...The .357 mag is about the minimum in power for protection against large predators or against large game. That doesn't mean that It's ineffective, just that there has to be a cutoff somewhere. The 10mm loaded to the gills and fired from a longer specialty barrel, can approach a hot loaded .357 fired from a 4" barrel.Double Tap 200 grain Hard Cast. This 357 magnum load from Double Tap is the only one listed here that is more than 180 grains. Because it’s a bigger projectile it moves at a slightly lower, yet still respective, velocity. This one is rated by the company for 1200 feet per second at the muzzle, with 560 pounds of energy when fired from a 4 ...10mm 200 gr XTP, 7.1 grains CFE Pistol at 1060 fps. 44 mag 300 gr XTP, 17.5 grains H110 at 1093 fps. The 10mm is a true .400” caliber whereas the 44 actually measures .429” diameter. Interestingly enough, there was little velocity difference between the loads even with just over 10 more grains of powder in the 44 mag.37.9gr. Max Pressure. 35,000psi. 36,000psi. The .357 Mag is a much smaller diameter bullet than its .44 Mag counterpart. While the case and overall length are similar, the .44 Mag is much wider and voluminous cartridge that can hold more powder and withstand a higher amount of pressure when the powder is ignited.

Almost any center fire cartridge of 357 bore or larger with a very hard, non-expanding, flat-nosed bullet will pierce a bear's skull with direct /frontal (between the eyes) hits. From the side angle, shoot them right at the bottom of the ear canal. These two shots are instant death if you are using the correct ammo.

Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...This is no 40 vs 45 thread. More a "40" can pretty much hang with the 10mm in long barrels for bear defense, If the 220g and 230g bullets were more available and would stabilize better in the 10mm twist rates. This may be different. Pushing a hardcast WFN 200g@1200-1250 is just hard to beat in the .40/10mm bore.A huge boost to the popularity of the 10mm is the trend of foregoing the traditionally accepted .44 Magnum (or larger) revolver in favor of the lighter, higher-capacity 10mm for bear defense. The 10mm has generated a pretty good track record of defense against grizzlies and brown bears, and a 10mm is much easier to carry and shoot …Brown bear shot by policemen s after attack on veterinarian,police uses that time (2010) 9mm Makarov, I'm pretty sure about 95% it was basic FMJ (Full metal ...In order for the 357 Magnum to perform at the level of a 10mm cartridge, it has to be at pressures beyond 40000 CUP and that performance will only come from strong N frames (or stronger). The L frame (586/686) is rated under the 40000 CUP level. And even at those high pressure levels (40000+ CUP), the 10mm is still a better performer (by a very ...9mm VS a Bear Thread starter thebusinessend; ... .41mag is considered the minimum for bear hunting. 10mm w/ 15rds+ or 200/230gr hardcast/FMJ is considered the minimum for bear protection. ... The most powerful handgun I own is a .357 mag. Therefore, I'd bring bear spray and then shoot the thing. RI_John. Joined Mar 12, 2009 Messages 2,466 Likes 618

It can get your attention, but nothing like the 10mm. The 9mm generates around 4 ft./lbs. of energy .. ok, maybe up to 6 or so depending on the load and the weight of the pistol firing it. The 10mm starts at around 10 ft./lbs. and can go up to 12 or more. That's double the felt recoil of the 9mm.

Minimum caliber is 4x against bear. Follow the 4-3-1 rule. 4x caliber and up. 300 grain and up. At least 1000 FPS. Your 5.56 meets only one criterion. Many people carry a 45-70. I carry a Ruger Alaskan 454 Casull or a …

Testing out 10mm, .357 Magnum and .44 Magnum using loads that all have the same bullet weight and similar energy to test the difference in sectional density....The .357 magnum revolver with hardcast bullets has even more "oomph" than 10mm. For a similar sized gun, a .44 mag has even more. For the 9 vs 10 argument, penetration, so projectile type is key. A 10mm 135gr Gold Dot isn't going to be as effective as a 9mm 147g hardcast. Why do these threads pop up weekly?Grizzly/Kodiak Pistol: 357 vs 41 vs 44 vs 10mm. Had a discussion with a buddy last night and thought I would see what Gunnit's opinion is. Looking for a pack gun, pistol, carried in shoulder or chest holster, in Kodiak country, Alaska. Most popular is big caliber revolvers, 357 up through 500. 357 is really on the small end though, and 44 mag ...10mm is a much smaller number of significantly larger sized frame .45 type guns like the 1911 / S&W 1006 / Glock 20 sized gun. Using full power 10mm for self defense is silly, as you have much more recoil and flash, without any significant increase in stopping power (according to the statistics) vs. a .40 S&W.10mm- Good woods option. Just know that most affordable 10mm will still be expensive, and all you'll really get is a 40sw. 357sig- Fun, precise, but financially impractical. There are 9mm and 40sw defense rounds that mirror 357sig ballistically.Jun 1, 2010 · Jun 5, 2012. #10. I found the following on another (Smith-wessonforum.com) forum for what it's worth: The absolute best Factory 357 Magnum "Bear Load" ammunition is the HSM® 180gr RNFL Gas Check. Ballistics are 1489fps and 886fpe (#HSM-357-18-N). Second best is Buffalo Bore® 180gr LFN-GC @ 1400fps and 783fpe (#19A/20). Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...Originally Posted by OSOKSo, Kevin, why are you getting in so many fights with black bears? Are you out there calling them names or something? Lotsa youth, not much brains. I have mellowed in my later years and I now no longer push any issue with a bear unless he's on my property. Have...In reality the best trail gun is a short barrel rifle , like the Win 94 in 30-30

Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...Bear Load ammo is primarily handgun calibers loaded with heavy, hard-cast bullets known for bone-crushing penetration on big game. ... Both categories include the .357 Magnum, 10mm Auto, .41 Remington Magnum, .44 Magnum, .45 Colt, .454 Casull, .460 S&W Magnum, and .500 S&W Magnum. There is also a Bear Load option for the .45-70 Government. I ...10mm is plenty for black bear. As George pointed out, there is a WORLD of difference between a blackie and a griz. But here's a question, IF you are going to buy a new gun, why not get a Ruger Redhawk in 44 magnum or 45 Long Colt.Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...Instagram:https://instagram. p0456 code dodge ram 1500estate sales near collierville tnrepublic bank draft roomjames jimmy i inendino I compare the 10mm and the 44 magnum cartridges, weighing their strengths and weaknesses for the role of bear defense.Check out the new video where we use th... airport stadium 12 409 aviation blvd santa rosa ca 95403low tide today virginia beach Primer Type: Boxer. Casing Type: Nickel-Plated Brass. Muzzle Velocity:1250 FPS. Muzzle Energy: 694 ft-lbs. Pros. Feeds reliably. Hi-Tek Polymer-coated hard-cast bullet reduces …Originally Posted by OSOKSo, Kevin, why are you getting in so many fights with black bears? Are you out there calling them names or something? Lotsa youth, not much brains. I have mellowed in my later years and I now no longer push any issue with a bear unless he's on my property. Have... star note dollar2 bill Gummy bears are probably one of you child's favorite snacks; they are tasty and irresistibly cute. But when your child drops a gummy bear in your car, it often goes unnoticed until...10mm vs .357 Sig, really about the recoil and recovering for 2nd shot, right (if $ is not an issue)? It is more about the shooter's abilities and comfort. ... As for defense aginst bear, and that being subjective, it will easily dispatch black bears. However for the large grizzly or kodiaks, I would want nothing less than a 45-70. Having said ...